The origin of a movement...

Nov 21, 2005,04:16 AM
 

is a mine field, stories often conflicts with each other depending on sources. Even watch historian being employed by brands sometimes found different versions of movement origins confusing.

Group histories was muddled and likelo to continue even in the future (Even today, I have heard arguable jokes like Cartier feeds the other richemont brands or similarly Swatch watches do the same for Blancpain etc) all of which made interesting anecdotes.

The truth is, all established brands and group had their roller coaster financial rides. As a movement supplier since the 19th centuries, MJLC must have supplied movements for many for vastly different reasons during different period of times to various brands. And all reasons are probably valid and true at one time or another.

Distracting myself from the topic a little, famous watch brands have depended on movement suppliers as far as watch history can remembers. Many Geneva brands for example paid little respect to the dilligent watchmakers who supplied them the movements. Brands ordered movements of their choice from the much despised "farmer class" watchmakers on the pretext that they are the one providing for the farmers' livelihood.

If anything has changed. more and more brands are using inhouse design and manufactured movement today, more and more movement suppliers are being acknowledged and there is more truth in advertising today than anytime in the past. A situation where significant credits must be given to The Swatch Group and perhaps growing culture of watch appreciation.

Jaw

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

What different companies does MJLC manufacturer base movements for ?

 
 By: Dhiraj Doshi : November 15th, 2005-11:11
Dear All, I am a complete Jaeger-LeCoultre fan .I just bought myself a Master Compressor Dulamatic and put a dark brown horn back strap on it .I think it is the most beautiful watch i have ever owned . While i made my purchase i was told that JLC manufact... 

JLC movements

 
 By: Aalok : November 15th, 2005-12:24
Congratulations on the new Master Compressor Dualmatic. That is one of my favorite watches & contains a brand new movement design from JLC. You can be confident that JLC produces extremely high quality movements. There is a long history within the Swiss w... 

Very considered answer thanks!

 
 By: Jaw : November 15th, 2005-08:20
I have done some compilation of movements supply to th industiw my own for some years. In the history of jlc, it was more than ebauch supplies. Many famous pieces were in fact made for other famous brands. Will post when i am home. Jaw posted via nokia n7... 

I'm particularly thinking of AP and VC

 
 By: Gary : November 15th, 2005-09:21
Seems that many VCs I look at have characteristic signs of JLC movements! For example, isn't the Toledo based on the same movement as the JLC MM? Then there's the AP Millenary Maserati two time-zone watch whose sub-dial placement is suspiciously like that... 

There is no need to be "suspicious" about it; it is openly acknowledged fact that

 
 By: ThomasM : November 16th, 2005-02:14
the two "superlative" movements of the 20th century, the AP/VC 2003/1003, and the AP/VC 2120/1120, were JLC developments, initiated and funded by AP and VC (and in the second case, by PP as well) The manual wind ultra thin was itself based upon a L.E. Pig... 

Thanks a lot guys

 
 By: Dhiraj Doshi : November 16th, 2005-07:07

Are you sure of everything...

 
 By: Dje : November 16th, 2005-02:02
for what I have seen MJLC delivers also (mainly?) finished and assembled movements for their main customers. They also deliver to Van Cleef et Arpels, and it seems that they deliver Piaget too (just for one watch). I know that Lemania delivers also some a... 

Not sure of ebauches delivery vs. completed movements.

 
 By: Aalok : November 16th, 2005-04:04
I don't know the details of companies which used complete movements vs. those which used ebauches for their watches. I'd like to learn more about JLC's role as a movement supplier, so I would welcome any information on this topic. Here is a very brief lis... 

Yes...

 
 By: Dje : November 16th, 2005-06:06

non exhaustive list...

 
 By: Jaw : November 21st, 2005-04:16

Thanks alok

 
 By: Dhiraj Doshi : November 16th, 2005-07:07

JLC - AP

 
 By: Felix : November 16th, 2005-07:07
Probably worth noting AP had an equity stake in JLC, A stake they sold to Richemont and partly used to finance the America's cup initiative. Regards

They also used some of the proceeds from the sale to complete the ownership

 
 By: ThomasM : November 16th, 2005-01:13
of Renaud et Papi, arguably one of the greatest high complications specialists extant today. TM

And part of the deal was also...

 
 By: Dje : November 17th, 2005-12:12
the rights and tools of caliber 2120, if I understood well (please Thomas correct if I'm wrong)! If so 2120 would be a real 100% manufacture caliber for AP now.

Non exhaustive list...but the info collected so far, all rights reserved...

 
 By: Jaw : November 16th, 2005-08:08
This is based on what I know, listed are various movements supplied throughout the period stated (may not be continuous supplied throughtout the period) and may or may not be the current situation, some watches supplied are complete watches, others are wh... 

Excellent, interesting list. I would caution readers, though, to bear in mind that

 
 By: ThomasM : November 16th, 2005-01:13
Jaw intended his list to include brands which were supplied movements - complete or ebauche - by JLC, from JLC's side. I am sure he did not mean to imply (as might be easily mistakenly concluded) that these brands relied EXCLUSIVELY on JLC movements, comp... 

Thanks for clarifying things.

 
 By: Aalok : November 16th, 2005-05:17
I enjoy looking into the historical connections in the Swiss watch industry, especially regarding JLC & F. Piguet. These topics can often be misinterpreted and serve as the foundation for making value judgements on the various companies involved. This is ... 

I made a typographical error in my earlier post, which you repeated here...

 
 By: ThomasM : November 16th, 2005-06:18
Hi, Aalok, That should have been L.E. Piguet, not F. Piguet. The LE Piguet origins of the cal. 1003/2003 manual ultra thin are not widely known, and I only found out about it after decades of interest in the industry, and then only because of a fortuitous... 

Thanks for the compliments

 
 By: Aalok : November 20th, 2005-08:20

and Breguet

 
 By: ei8htohms : November 16th, 2005-04:16
Hi Guys, In addition to the JLC based Breguet calibers already listed in this thread (Cal. 549 and 530), Breguet also used the JLC Cal. 839 ultrathin, calling it Breguet Cal. 509 (or possibly 503, I can't remember which, the other one is the Breguet versi... 

Ok - JAW beat me there... nt

 
 By: DeVille : November 16th, 2005-09:09