what to do with it now

Feb 04, 2013,03:47 AM
 

I think you certainly should contact the seller if you believe that he consciously tried to pass it as authentic / all original WT and if you challenged it on this aspect and he lied (and of course if he sold the watch with a premium because of the WT feature).

If he sold the watch as a 'fantasy dial' i.e. repainted in a scheme which was not like the original one, and both of you agreed on this, then it is fine, both parties know what has been sold.

Now, I must say this redial is of relatively good quality from an aesthetic point of view, so you might enjoy wearing the watch for its look. But it has very little collectors value (again, that might not be a problem if it is not what you were looking for).

Had the watch kept its sliver dial - and only had a fake WT inner dial - you would still have had the option to replace the inner WT dial with a plain one to make the watch legit again  (this was an intersting memo in its original shape, being US and Stainless Steel (rare), and with a rare dial with the VI and IX markers).
With both dials painted black, the hunt for this special dial might be a real challenge.

 

I hope you won't lose too much in the process, or that you will enjoy wearing it nonetheless

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Memovox roll call

 
 By: agyzace : January 29th, 2013-01:06
Since I saw another roll call, I thought about calling for a Memovox one Best regards to all, Alexandros...  

famous

 
 By: OlivierT : January 29th, 2013-02:20
you know Sir, this is one of the famous watches. one of my preferred. (with the polaris). nice taste Sir.

I just awfully realized that....

 
 By: amanico : January 29th, 2013-09:40
I had no Modern Memovoxes, except the Diving ones... Damn! I have to find that Black Memo Cal 914 I am hunting for years, now! Superb, Alexandros. Really. Nicolas

I would have never thought that this is possible

 
 By: agyzace : January 29th, 2013-10:07
Hi Nicolas, Thank you very much for your message. I was counting on you for a few nice vintage ones. :) I will try to post a picture of my hand wound Memovox which dates back to the 50's or 60's. I do not remember to be honest the exact year. It is fascin... 

Aaah, in this case, if we can play outside the modern and non diving!

 
 By: amanico : January 29th, 2013-10:25
Here we go! - E 851: - 3161 Parking: - E 855, black, and white: - E 872: - E 877: Well, for once, I will not post the Memovox Diving ( I have 6 of them ), as you know them by heart. ;) Best, Nicolas ...  

I knew it :)

 
 By: agyzace : January 29th, 2013-11:11
These are some seriously beautiful watches...! Thanks for sharing with us, Nicolas. Amazing collection, you have there. Have a great evening and thanks again, Alexandros

I would like to play with you....

 
 By: Clavi : January 29th, 2013-16:00
....but I could only find this one picture in my hard drive : ...  

LOL - good one, Clavi!

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 29th, 2013-21:48
Now show us big pic version! :) Best Blomman

Add five ...

 
 By: stromer : February 1st, 2013-02:22
... and you have got two complete decks or cards. You win! (As nobody would have expected different :-) ) Best, Martin

this is a fun one, like it :-)

 
 By: FanFrancisco : February 4th, 2013-04:36

Stunning line up, Nicolas! :)

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 29th, 2013-12:49
But are you sure this is a good idee?! Remember last time we played this game...? ;) Best, my friend Blomman

LOL! :) Yes... [nt]

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 29th, 2013-13:29

So, I will try to play it under the radar...

 
 By: amanico : January 29th, 2013-13:40
Unless we are speaking of Vintage Diving Memos, but even at this game, you're pretty good! ;) Best, Nicolas

A pair and four Aces?

 
 By: stromer : January 30th, 2013-04:51
Sure you are not cheating ;-) Wonderful samples you have, Nicolas! With your white 855 being the one that led me onto the dangerously steep Memovox slope :-) Best, Martin

Master Memovox :)

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 29th, 2013-12:48
Alexandros, it is a pleasure to this one here - not many around in the forum... Best Blomman

OK, I will play a few cards...

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 29th, 2013-13:36
Master Memovox (Cal 914). Master Reveil. Master International. Best Blomman ...  

Aaaargh, the first one!!! Damn black beauty!

 
 By: amanico : January 29th, 2013-13:42
One day, it will be mine... I HAVE to get it! Best, Nicolas

you know my problem with this one. Like if there was some kind of

 
 By: amanico : January 29th, 2013-14:04
Sortilege on me, as each time i tought I could grab one, it escpaed from me. Now, I wonder who put this sortilege on me... If I ever dsicover the guilty guy.... Hmmmmm.... Best, Vlad. ...  

LOL - it was me! ;) [nt]

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 29th, 2013-14:08

my memovoxs model

 
 By: zewok : January 30th, 2013-13:10
E855 E855 Ebene E875 bicolore E875 Bleue E11005 ...  

Very nice display! :)

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 31st, 2013-13:34
I should find correct hans for my E 11005... Best Blomman

I will play one more hand - two pairs...

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 29th, 2013-21:53
3161 Memovox Parking E 872 Best Blomman ...  

LOL - OK, I raise, three of a kind! :)

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 30th, 2013-08:16
E 877 Snowdrop. Best Blomman ...  

Small straight... ;)

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 30th, 2013-12:20
3150 - 3151 Best Blomman ...  

Flush....

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 30th, 2013-12:40
3072 E 876 Best Blomman ...  

Full house....

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 30th, 2013-12:46
E 875 E 861 Best Blomman ...  

Ok, last one for tonight - four of a kind....

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 30th, 2013-12:50
E 855 Best Blomman ...  

::)))

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 30th, 2013-13:04

OMG .. What a Display .. Humble me ..

 
 By: hs111 : January 30th, 2013-13:18
.. thus, I can only tap my hat to you ! - standing by the card table and watch the Grand Masters play ! In silent but friendly awe, humbly yours & best, hs PS: - well, at least for three of these four 855's, I can share the joy, mostly thanks to two good ... 

Hey KoC! :)

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 31st, 2013-13:36
Thank you for your always so kind words, my friend! Please join in and show us your beautiful ladies - I know you have a lot of them! :) Best Blomman

OK, I fold... I got nothing...

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 31st, 2013-13:39
3041. E 871. Best Blomman ...  

Honestly? I don't know...

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 31st, 2013-13:45
Like the E 855 - more than allowed in Poker...! Best Blomman ...  

Counting on Clavi for that one....! ;)

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 30th, 2013-13:07

The 3150 is one of my regrets. I shoulkd have considered a beautiful one

 
 By: amanico : January 30th, 2013-12:53
Which was offered tom e, a few years ago... These Tubular Lugs + the fact that it is the first Memo make it a very inteesting model, to consider in any serious Memo collection. Best, Nicolas

Well, Mr. Black

 
 By: stromer : January 30th, 2013-04:52
these are fine pieces! And great photographs also! Best, Martin

Thank you, Martin! :) [nt]

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 30th, 2013-08:12

This time I can play

 
 By: stromer : January 29th, 2013-13:49
as I have two Aces in my small deck :-) Plain Memovox I: Plain Memovox II : Have a great day! Martin ...  

Snake eyes! ;)

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 29th, 2013-14:00
Beautiful pair, Martin! :) A great classic pair - one vintage, one modern... Perfect combo! Best Blomman

My grandfather's:

 
 By: SteveG : January 29th, 2013-14:32
mid-1950s, gold filled (restored): ...  

One & only Memovox

 
 By: jml_watches : January 29th, 2013-14:51
Hi Here's mine & I'm afraid that it'll torment Nicholas again No black dial! Cheers JML ...  

Gone, but not forgotten

 
 By: Ed. W : January 30th, 2013-18:41
...  

That is one of the few Lecoultre Memo that I am considering

 
 By: amanico : January 30th, 2013-22:23
adding in my collection, because of the shpae of the numbers. I am totally crazy about that dial! Best, Nicolas

I just picked this one up today!

 
 By: rovermark : February 1st, 2013-23:45
I had meant to post my TT Polaris and TT Deep Sea but hadn't yet. That's ok though because I ended up buying a Memovox earlier today. So far only one bad picture of it. I'll have to shoot more tomorrow. ...  

Interesting, but there is a but

 
 By: Clavi : February 2nd, 2013-14:12
I don't want to be the one bringing the bad news here, but just in case you might have had doubts when buying it, or if you have been mis-sold a WT by the seller, you should be warned that this watch has a non-original / repainted dial, which was original... 

This is the problem with impulse buys

 
 By: rovermark : February 4th, 2013-00:55
I saw it at a watch show and I hadn't done my homework. It just appealed to me so I bought it. Now I have to decide (quickly) if I'm going to contact the seller or just keep it. Even if it isn't correct I have to admit that I like it.

When it comes to Memovox WTs, doing your homework is a pretty hard thing.

 
 By: amanico : February 4th, 2013-01:00
Most of thse I saw for sale are not authentic, my friend. Do not feel too guilty, here. Best, Nicolas

what to do with it now

 
 By: Clavi : February 4th, 2013-03:47
I think you certainly should contact the seller if you believe that he consciously tried to pass it as authentic / all original WT and if you challenged it on this aspect and he lied (and of course if he sold the watch with a premium because of the WT fea... 

Room for one more?

 
 By: george r curry : February 3rd, 2013-02:29
Sadly this old friend spends most of his time locked up, he deserves a pass for good behaviour soon. This is #0006 looking for #0001 if he is around? Reveil ...  

my 2 humble memovox...

 
 By: FanFrancisco : February 3rd, 2013-07:58
... among my memovox collection, these two i would like to add this roll call. stefan ...  

Black dial !

 
 By: tombub : February 4th, 2013-07:18
Tiens bon Nico... ;) ...  

Naaaard.... ! :) A conspiracy!

 
 By: amanico : February 4th, 2013-07:20
I have to stay cool, I have to stay cool, I have to srtay cool..... ;) Merci, l'ami. Nicolas.